Nathan (vovat) wrote,

Well, I'll be a country's uncle!

The Land of Oz has been cited as the first truly American fairyland, and there's probably a good deal of truth to that. Even today, fantasy seems to be dominated by British authors. L. Frank Baum might not have been the first American fantasy author, but perhaps he was the first to create an entire fantasy world that had special significance to Americans. The only other author I know of who set out to write specifically American fairy tales was Carl Sandburg, with his Rootabaga Stories, and that was after Baum's time. Still, while there are plenty of American elements in Oz, it still has elements of fairy tales from the old country, not least of which being in the fact that it is, as the Scarecrow tells Benny in Ruth Plumly Thompson's The Giant Horse of Oz, a "magical monarchy," rather than a republic. So, all in all, it comes across as a little odd that John R. Neill would want to bring in Uncle Sam as an Oz character. He is, after all, not quite as universal as Santa Claus or the Easter Bunny.

To provide more details, the heroes in Lucky Bucky in Oz visit Wise Acres, a country club with a membership made up entirely of uncles. Uncle Sam is the president, and he is described as "tall, not fat like the others, and had a tuft of whiskers on the end of his chin." The picture of him that appears on page 226 of the book shows him looking a lot like he does on the military recruitment posters, but without his top hat, and his clothing "not at all star-spangled" (as John Bell puts it in the Nonestica discussion of the book). Bucky immediately recognizes Sam as his own uncle, but does he mean this literally, or simply in the sense that all Americans are metaphorical nephews and nieces of Uncle Sam? We never really find out, although the explanation I've thought up is that it's a little of both. Sam was an uncle of Bucky's who somehow came to Oz, and took on the role of his famous namesake. Since Americans have been prominent in shaping the recent history of Oz, he felt at home there, and decided to stay. Whether Columbia and Brother Jonathan are also hanging around somewhere in Ozma's dominions remains to be seen.

I think the reason why the American symbol shows up in an Oz book might be because it was published in 1942, by which time the United States had fully thrown itself into World War II. The rear dust jacket flap of Lucky Bucky originally included a note attributed to Bucky himself, telling readers to buy war bonds because "[t]he Nazis and Japs are harder to beat than the Gnomes." Sam is never a major character in the story (he doesn't even show up until close to the end), but I think his presence is probably a reflection of wartime patriotism.
Tags: books, characters, oz

  • Social Network Distancing

    I started working from home this week. It's convenient not to have to get ready or go in to work, which I pretty much dread doing. On the other hand,…

  • Winter Breakage

    I'm going to write a little about the winter holidays, although really that was only a few days with regular work days in between them. I did take…

  • Trimmings and Trappings

    I've been meaning to write a life update, but I've had a lot going on as of late, and even when I didn't I found other things to do. Beth and I did…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.