Nathan (vovat) wrote,
Nathan
vovat

Still Pottering

So, I've now seen the film version of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince. I honestly hadn't been thinking much about Harry Potter recently, except sometimes in the context of comparing aspects of it to other fantasy universes. I guess part of the problem is that so much of the promotion for the books involved mysteries about what would happen in the next book that, once the last book came out, there wasn't really that much more to think about. So when I started seeing advertisements for the new movie, it had me thinking, "Oh, that's right! They still haven't finished making those movies!" Anyway, I watched it tonight with bethje and Uncle John, and here are some of my thoughts on it:


Overall, I liked it pretty well, and think it didn't seem as rushed as some of the previous films. It's difficult for someone who's read the book NOT to evaluate the movies in terms of what they left out, but I suppose most of the stuff that they omitted wasn't strictly necessary to the plot. In fairness, I'm sure it's a real balancing act condensing a long book into a reasonable-length movie while not contradicting it in any significant way. I would have liked to see more of Tom Riddle's past and some scenes of Snape actually TEACHING Defense Against the Dark Arts, but you can't have everything. Besides, if I remember correctly, most of what we got from Snape's class in the book involved non-verbal spells, which turned out not to be particularly important anyway. Then again, why was it necessary to throw in the scene with the Death Eaters burning the Weasleys' house? And since when is Lavender Brown a white girl? For that matter, I still haven't gotten over their changing Flitwick for no apparent reason.

One thing Beth mentioned after the movie was how mild the scenes in the cave turned out to be. Dumbledore's reaction to the potion was much less severe than it sounded in the book. It was supposed to cause him severe pain, while it just came across as mild distaste in the film. Along the same lines, I noticed that the results of Sectumsempra were nowhere near as gruesome as Rowling described them. Maybe this was just to keep the PG-13 rating, but they made the scenes less intense than they really should have been. Also not particularly intense was Hagrid's mourning over Aragog.


And, well, that's probably about all for Harry Potter until the next movie comes out.
Tags: books, harry potter, movies
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 2 comments